top of page

Menu

OUR

262-251-3320

Menu



Butter Burgers



Small Butter Hamburger

1/8LB hamburger

$2.79

Burger Mods

Bacon

$0.99

Pepperjack Cheese

$0.60

Provolone Cheese

$0.60

Jumbo Butter Hamburger

1/4LB patty

$4.99

Burger Mods

Bacon

$0.99

Pepperjack Cheese

$0.60

Provolone Cheese

$0.60

Double Small Butter Hamburger

(2x 1/8LB patties)

$4.39

Burger Mods

Bacon

$0.99

Pepperjack Cheese

$0.60

Provolone Cheese

$0.60

Double Jumbo Butter Hamburger

(2x 1/4LB patties)

$7.99

Burger Mods

Bacon

$0.99

Pepperjack Cheese

$0.60

Provolone Cheese

$0.60

Black Angus Hamburger

1/3LB Black Angus Hamburger

$8.50

Burger Mods

Bacon

$0.99

Pepperjack Cheese

$0.60

Provolone Cheese

$0.60

Double Black Angus Hamburger

2x 1/3LB Black Angus Patties

$10.99

Burger Mods

Bacon

$0.99

Pepperjack Cheese

$0.60

Provolone Cheese

$0.60

Double Grilled Cheese Black Angus

A burger where the buns are made out of grilled cheese? Yes. Black Angus 1/3LB patty served on white or wheat grilled cheese. (Choice of toppings: Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo, Fried or Raw Onion, Ketchup, Mustard, Pickle)

$12.99

Double Grilled Cheese Black Angus

Patty Melt

Jumbo Cheese Burger on Grilled Rye or Sour Dough Bread (Pictured on Rye Bread with onion rings)

$7.99

Rye/Wheat

Rye Bread

Wheat Bread

Patty Melt

Ranch Burger

(Jumbo Burger, W/Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo, Cheese, Bacon & Onion)

$9.99

Ranch Burger

Sub Burger

(Double Cheese Burger, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo & Onion, Served on French Bread)

$7.99

Sub Burger

Turkey Burger

Turkey burger patty served on bun. (Choice of: Ketchup, Mustard, Fried or Raw Onion, Pickles)

$8.50

Burger Mods

Bacon

$0.99

Pepperjack Cheese

$0.60

Provolone Cheese

$0.60



Additional Toppings



Bacon

$0.99


Cheese

(Pepperjack, Provolone, Swiss or American)

$0.59


Lettuce and Tomato

$0.69


Mushrooms

$0.99




Sandwiches



Grilled Cheese

White or Wheat bread.

$2.99


Stacked Ham Sandwich

Available on white, wheat, or gluten-free bread.

$6.59

Stacked Ham Sandwich

Ham & Cheese Sub

(Hot or Cold)

$7.99


Turkey Sandwich

$4.99


Turkey Sub

$6.49


BLT Sandwich

$4.99

BLT Sandwich

BLT Sub

$7.99


Gluten-Free Bread

Sandwiches available on gluten-free bread.

$1.65




Specialty Sandwiches



Pizza Burger

(Jumbo Cheese Burger w/Pizza Sauce)

$6.99


Smoked BBQ Pulled Pork

Smoked pork shoulder with BBQ sauce. (Pictured with breaded mushrooms)

$7.59

Smoked BBQ Pulled Pork

Ultimate Grilled Cheese

(Sourdough bread with Swiss and American cheese, tomato, raw onion and bacon) Pictured with cup of chili.

$7.99

Ultimate Grilled Cheese

Tuna Sandwich

White or wheat toasted bread. Lettuce, tomato, mayo, onion)

$6.59


Tuna Melt

(Tuna Salad on Grilled Rye or Sour Dough Bread with melted cheese) Choice of Swiss of American cheese.

$7.99

Rye/Sourdough

Rye

Sourdough


Ham & Cheese Melt

(Rye or Sour Dough Bread, Swiss or American Cheese)

$7.99


Veggie Melt

(Cheese, Tomato, Mushroom, and Fried or Raw Onion on Rye or Sour Dough Bread)

$7.99


Grilled Pork Chop Sandwhich

Grilled pork chop served on choice of French bread or bun. (Available with Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo, Onion)

$9.99

French or Bun

French Bread

Bun




Chicken



Grilled Chicken Sandwich

(Served with Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo & Onion)

$9.99


Breaded Chicken Sandwich

(Served with Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo & Onion)

$9.99


Chicken Cordon Bleu

(Grilled or Breaded chicken. On grilled sourdough bread or bun)

$9.99


Chicken Tenders

$7.99

Chicken Tenders

Santa Fe Chicken Sandwich

Grilled or Breaded chicken sandwich with American cheese, bacon, and BBQ sauce. (Pictured with onion rings)

$9.99

Grilled/Breaded

Grilled Chicken

Breaded Chicken

Santa Fe Chicken Sandwich

Chicken Parm Sandwhich

Breaded or grilled chicken breast served with melty provolone cheese, marinara sauce, and parmesan cheese.

$9.99

Breaded or Grilled

Breaded Chicken

Grilled Chicken




Fish & Shrimp



Jumbo Fish Sandwich

$7.99


4 Piece Fish Dinner

(Cod, Fries, Coleslaw & Rye Bread)

$12.49

4 Piece Fish Dinner

4 Piece Fish Combo

(Cod, Fries & Soda)

$12.49


12 Piece Fish Bucket

(Cod, Fries, & Tarter Sauce)

$26.99


Extra Piece of Fish

Extra piece of fish for your fish dinner, fish bucket, fish combo, or fish sandwich.

$1.99


Shrimp Dinner

(8 Shrimp, Sauce, Slaw, Rye Bread & French Fries)

$12.49


Shrimp Combo

(8 Shrimp, Sauce, Fries & Soda)

$12.49


Shrimp Bucket

(30 Shrimp, Fries & Sauce)

$26.99




Hot Dogs & Brats



Hot Dog

Small

$3.99


Large

$4.99


Chicago Red Hot 1/4 LB

$5.99

Chicago Red Hot 1/4 LB

Jumbo Chili Cheese Dog

$5.99


1/3 LB Klements Bratwurst

$5.99




Sides



Small Fries

$2.09


Large Fries

$3.39


Family Size Fries

$4.99


Cheddar Cheese or Ranch Fries

Family-sized fries with a side of cheese or ranch.

$5.69


Chili Cheese Fries

Family-sized fries with our homemade chili and cheese on top.

$6.99


Loaded Fries

Seasoned Fries with Cheese, Sour Cream, Bacon & Chives

$6.99

Loaded Fries

Onion Rings

$3.49


Breaded Mushrooms

Choice of ranch or marinara sauce.

$4.69

Ranch or Marinara

Ranch

Marinara

Breaded Mushrooms

Popcorn

$2.99


ColeSlaw

$1.29

ColeSlaw

Side Order of Cheese Sauce

$0.69


Mini Corn Dogs

$3.99


Cheese Curds

$4.69


Big Pickle

It's a big pickle.

$0.99




Soups

(Seasonal) Chilli w/cheese served year-round



Cup

Choice side of bread or crackers.

$3.59

BreadorCrackers

Bread

Crackers


Bowl

Choice side of bread or crackers.

$4.99

BreadorCrackers

Bread

Crackers


Quart

Hot or Cold

$11.99

BreadorCrackers

Bread

Crackers




Kid's Combo

Small entrée, drink, and kid cone/dish.



Chicken Tenders

2pc. Chicken Tenders w/ side of ranch. Includes small fries, small milk/chocolate milk, kid's cone/dish of custard.

$6.99


Breaded Mini Corndogs

4pc Breaded Mini Corn dogs. Includes small fries, small milk/chocolate milk, kid's cone/dish of custard.

$6.99


Grilled Cheese

Grilled Cheese (White or Wheat bread). Includes small fries, small milk/chocolate milk, kid's cone/dish of custard.

$6.99




Drinks



Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Fanta Orange, Lemonade, or Sprecher Root Beer

Large

$1.99


Coffee or Milk

$1.99


Hot Chocolate

$2.49


Ice Tea

Brewed Fresh

$1.99




Fountain



Malts & Shakes

Hot Fudge, Chocolate Syrup, Caramel, Butterscotch, Cherry, Strawberry, Pineapple, Banana, Peanut Butter Syrup, Marshmallow Sauce, Mint Marshmallow Sauce

Small

$5.99


Large

$6.99


Extra Thick

$0.30


Floats

Made with Sprecher root beer or any soft drink on tap.

Small

$3.99


Large

$4.59

Floats

Black Cow

Similar to a root beer float but blended.

Small

$5.99


Large

$6.99


Snow Storm

Blended custard with fruit or candy mix-ins. Thick and delicious! No additional milk added like a shake.

$8.99


Old Fashioned Custard Soda

(Chocolate, Lime & Cherry)

$4.99


Sundaes

Single topping - Hot Fudge, Chocolate Syrup, Caramel, Butterscotch, Cherry, Strawberry, Pineapple, Banana, Peanut Butter Syrup, Marshmallow Sauce, Mint Marshmallow Sauce & Malt Powder

Small

$4.69


Large

$6.99


TOPPINGS:

Hot Fudge, Chocolate Syrup, Caramel, Butterscotch, Cherry, Strawberry, Pineapple, Banana,Peanut Butter Syrup, Marshmallow Sauce, Mint Marshmallow Sauce & Malt Powder




Specialty Sundaes - SM/LG

Small Specialty Sundae: $4.99 Large Specialty Sundae: $7.99



Raspberry

$4.99


Turtle

Hot Fudge, Caramel & Pecans

Small

$4.99


Large

$7.99

Turtle

Jiminy Cricket

Hot Fudge, Mint Marshmallow & Chocolate Jimmies

Small

$4.99


Large

$7.99


Mom's Desire

Hot Fudge, Bananas & Chopped Nuts

$4.99


Pop's Delight

Hot Fudge, Strawberries, & Chopped Nuts

$4.99


Peanut Butter Kiss

Hot Fudge & Peanut Butter Sauce

$4.99


Puppy Chow

Peanut Butter sauce & Puppy Chow Pieces

$4.99

Puppy Chow

Caramel Cashew

Caramel Syrup & Cashews

$4.99


Tin Roof

(Hot Fudge & Spanish Peanuts)

Small

$4.99


Large

$6.99


Kiss Under The Roof

(Hot Fudge, Peanut Butter Syrup & Spanish Peanuts)

-

$4.99


Doug's Rocky Road

(Chocolate Custard, Marshmallows & Pecans)

-

$4.99


Brownie Treat

(Home baked Brownie, Vanilla Custard, Hot Fudge & Whipped Cream)

$8.99


Banana Split

(Strawberries, Pineapple,Chocolate, Bananas, Chopped Nuts & Whipped Cream)

$12.99

Banana Split



Cones



Single

$2.85

Waffle Cone

Waffle Cone

$0.75

Double

$3.89

Waffle Cone

Waffle Cone

$0.75

Triple

$4.39

Waffle Cone

Waffle Cone

$0.75

Baby/Kids

$1.90




Custard Pints & Quarts



Pints

$5.99


Quarts

$10.50


ADDRESS

 

N87W16459 Appleton Ave,
Menomonee Falls, WI 53051

CONTACT

 

sale@popscustard.com

 

HOURS

 

CLOSED

MAILING LIST

bottom of page